Friday, September 26, 2025

Self Proclaimed Atheist Richard Dawkins and Data (not) Deleting Permanently from the Web

 
Estimated Reading Time: 4 minutes

Epigraph

“We record that which they send before and their footprints; and all things We have kept in a clear register.”

— Qur’an 36:12

Introduction

Richard Dawkins, in The God Delusion, makes a passing yet striking observation about the internet: once information is uploaded, it is exceedingly difficult to erase it permanently. Even when original sources are deleted, search engines retain cached versions, storing data that lingers beyond its apparent removal. This notion of persistent digital memory offers a fascinating point of reflection when read against Qur’anic descriptions of divine preservation and human accountability. 

Dawkins on Cached Memory:

“It is hard, however, to delete something permanently from the World Wide Web. Search engines achieve their speed partly by keeping caches of information, and these inevitably persist for a while even after the originals have been deleted.”

Here Dawkins highlights the tenacity of data, an almost inescapable digital trace that survives beyond deliberate human erasure.

Qur’anic Parallel

The Qur’an asserts a similar inevitability, but on a far deeper and metaphysical level. Regarding resurrection and the reassembly of human beings, it declares:

“Does man think that We will not assemble his bones? Yes indeed, We are able to proportion even his very fingertips.” (Qur’an 75:3–4)

This verse reminds humankind that nothing of their existence is lost to time. Even the unique pattern of fingerprints, a modern marker of identity, is preserved by the Divine.

Reflection: From Digital Persistence to Divine Memory

The persistence of cached data in our digital age provides a tangible metaphor for the Qur’anic worldview. Just as information online is never truly erased, the Qur’an teaches that no act, word, or trace of human life is lost. God’s record is far more precise and enduring than any technological memory, extending to the smallest anatomical detail.

What Dawkins describes as an accident of technology — data stubbornly surviving deletion — becomes in the Qur’an a deliberate act of divine omniscience: the guarantee that all existence will be reassembled and accounted for.

Conclusion

The resonance between Dawkins’ scientific observation and the Qur’anic proclamation illustrates how modern realities echo age-old revelations. In both cases, the message is clear: nothing truly vanishes. The human tendency to forget or to hide is countered by a cosmic reality in which everything is preserved — whether in a server’s cache or in the divine register.

 

Aamir Yazdani

MPhil Islamic Thought & Civilization Pakistan

MSc Irrigation Engineering UK

No comments:

Post a Comment

Self Proclaimed Atheist Richard Dawkins and Data (not) Deleting Permanently from the Web

  Estimated Reading Time : 4 minutes ⸻ Epigraph “We record that which they send before and their footprints; and all things We have ke...