Monday, December 3, 2018

Playing God: When Judgement Clouds Reason: A Logos-Based Critique of Judgementalism in Islam (1st March, 2018)

Epigraph:

"Do not regard yourselves as pure; He is most knowing of who is righteous." — Qur’an 53:32

“Judge not, that ye be not judged.”— Jesus Christ (Matthew 7:1)

One of the most troubling ailments afflicting the contemporary Muslim psyche is the tendency to assume divine prerogatives—assigning salvation or damnation to others as though we possess the keys to Paradise and Hell. From pulpits to drawing rooms, the discourse has often devolved into passing judgments on who is worthy of God's mercy and who is irredeemably bound for Hellfire.

This attitude is not only theologically untenable—it borders on blasphemy. It is, in essence, “Playing God.” The Qur’an is unambiguous: only God knows the inner secrets of the heart. Regardless of their station, human beings have not been granted access to such divine knowledge. Even the Prophets themselves did not claim this authority. Only through revelation, mediated by the Archangel Gabriel, the Prophets came to know certain hidden matters—and even then, they exercised humility and restraint.

Indeed, the Prophets were embodiments of compassion, not condemnation. They prayed for their people—even for those who opposed them. The Qur'an recounts a poignant divine instruction to Prophet Muhammad:

“Whether you ask forgiveness for them or do not ask forgiveness for them—if you should ask forgiveness for them seventy times—never will Allah forgive them.”
(Qur’an 9:80)

This verse reflects not only the gravity of divine decree but also the Prophet's extraordinary capacity for mercy—persistently seeking forgiveness for even the most obstinate disbelievers.

The Qur'an reminds us of God's intimate knowledge of the soul’s whispers:

“And We have already created man and know what his soul whispers to him, and We are closer to him than [his] jugular vein.”
(Qur’an 50:16)

Parallel teachings are echoed in the Christian tradition. In the Sermon on the Mount, Prophet Jesus (peace be upon him) cautioned against self-righteous judgment:

“Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?”
(Matthew 7:3)

Both the Qur’anic and Biblical traditions converge on this moral imperative: humility before divine knowledge, mercy over judgment, and introspection over condemnation.

As Muslims, we are not tasked with sitting on God’s throne. We are called to walk humbly on His earth. To love, not to hate. To correct, not to curse. To guide, not to gloat. In this age of digital fatwas and viral denunciations, perhaps the greatest service we can render to our faith is to refrain from playing God—and to become human again.


Aamir Yazdani

No comments:

Post a Comment

Life Is a Cricket Test Match – It is Designed to Prove Your Mettle!

  "It's not about how fast you score, but how long you stay in the middle." — Anonymous cricket commentator Reading T...