Monday, May 25, 2026

The Moment of Reckoning – II (Q/A Session) by Mr. Rizwanullah (Translated in English)

Epigraph: And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” Qur’an 28:77

 Source Note: This is a direct English rendering of a recorded discussion between Mr. Rizwanullah (Scholar, Al Mawrid, Lahore) and young participants. The content has been translated faithfully into English with grammatical refinement, without interpretive additions.

 Question 1: When the Qur’an is studied carefully, one notices that while it repeatedly draws attention toward the final destination — the ultimate stage for which one must prepare — Allah specifically mentions one important reality:

Your wealth and your children are but a trial (fitnah)…”

The question often arises: if wealth and children are described as a fitnah (trial or test), then why does Islam also describe righteous children and beneficial wealth as sources of ongoing reward (sadaqah jariyah)?

Reply: The likely explanation given is this: wealth and children, by themselves, are not automatically a means of success in the Hereafter. Rather, they are tests that can either draw a person toward Allah or distract him away from Allah. Yet at the same time, we also see that Islam teaches: If your children are righteous, they continue praying for you and become a source of reward for you even after your death. If you spend your wealth in good causes, it continues benefiting you after you leave this world.

 So the real issue is not wealth or children themselves. The issue is how they are used, nurtured, and directed. If a person becomes so absorbed in wealth and family that they distract him from his responsibility toward Allah and the Hereafter, then they become a fitnah in the negative sense — a trial that causes failure.

 But if wealth is earned lawfully, spent righteously, and children are given proper moral and spiritual upbringing, then the very same things become among the greatest assets for the Hereafter.

 So these are not contradictory statements. Rather, they describe two possible outcomes of the same blessings. The Qur’an calls them a test because every test can lead either to success or failure depending on how a person responds to it. So is it really about how these things are used and how children are raised that transforms them into something beneficial, or are these two contradictory ideas?

 When the Qur’an uses the word fitnah regarding these things, fitnah here means a test or trial. Wealth, children, family — all these become a form of examination for human beings. In what sense are they an examination?

 Well, an examination means that a question has been placed before you. You may answer it correctly or incorrectly, but once the question appears, you have undeniably entered the test. Exactly on this principle, your children, your family, and your possessions become a continuous test for you. Now it depends on you how you pass through this examination.

 Both possibilities exist.

 Sometimes these very blessings gradually become a burden and a cause of ruin. How? When a person himself never turns toward faith, never thinks seriously about the Hereafter or preparation for accountability before Allah, and likewise never places those concerns into the minds of his children. Instead, he teaches them only the formulas of worldly success: how to become important, powerful, successful, wealthy, and socially accomplished. Their upbringing revolves entirely around worldly achievement.

 Now the very things that were granted to you as a test become, because of your response to them, not a means of salvation for the Hereafter but a source of loss.

 But now look at the other side. These same blessings can also become provisions for your eternal journey.

 There is a verse in the Qur’an that beautifully expresses this idea. Usually, people place verses like “Hādhā min fali Rabbī” (“This is from the فضل of my Lord”) or “Wallāhu khayrur-rāziqīn” (“Allah is the Best of providers”) in their homes. But the verse I have placed in my own home is this:And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” Qur’an 28:77

 Meaning: whatever Allah has granted you here — your family, your children, your home, your resources, your blessings — do not limit their use merely to worldly enjoyment and temporary comfort. Their real purpose is much greater: Use them to build your Hereafter. Take these blessings forward with you into the next life. Purchase the eternal world through them. Allah says:Seek the Home of the Hereafter through what Allah has given you.” One way is simply to eat, drink, enjoy, and remain absorbed in worldly pleasures. The other way is to use these blessings to construct your eternal life.

 If you look at your family and children with this perspective, then you not only help shape their Hereafter, but after your death, they continue helping shape yours as well. Through righteous upbringing, they pray for you, become a source of ongoing charity (sadaqah jariyah), and continue benefiting you even after you leave this world.

 So yes — that understanding is absolutely correct. ________________________________________________________________________________

Question 2: Some people plan their lives in such a way that during the earlier part of their lives, they commit every kind of wrongdoing. In their businesses, they engage in adulteration or do not work honestly. But their plan is that toward the last part of their lives, they will perform Hajj, all their sins will be forgiven, and after that, they will spend a few years in the remembrance of Allah.

 In this way, according to them, both their Hereafter and their worldly life will be secured. So is this attitude correct?

 Reply: Wrongdoing that happens suddenly — the Qur’an says that some people fall into sin because they are swept away by emotions. If that is the situation, then a return is also possible. A person repents, turns back, and God, too, comes forward and embraces him in His mercy. In fact, if I use the Qur’an’s own words, Allah says that for such a person who returns, it becomes binding upon Him that He will certainly accept his repentance: Indeed, repentance accepted by Allah is for those who commit wrongdoing out of ignorance…” (Surah An-Nisa 4:17)

 So this is one type of case. A believer generally makes mistakes in this manner. A person who has God in his heart, who has fear of God and concern for the Hereafter, is not free from mistakes altogether. Whenever he becomes involved in sin, it is this kind of lapse: it happens, but then he returns as well.

 But the second case — and I am again referring to the verse from Surah An-Nisa — is of those people who keep on committing wrong after wrong. Notice that the Qur’an used the singular form earlier: “those who commit a wrong” (ya‘malūna as-sū’a) — meaning someone who slips into a sin emotionally. But the second expression is: “they keep committing evil deeds” (ya‘malūna as-sayyi’āt) — mistake upon mistake, sin upon sin, continuously.

 First of all, this attitude itself cannot belong to a true believer. Then it takes on an even uglier form when planning becomes part of it — when a person decides: “I have fallen into continuous wrongdoing, and I will keep doing this. And how long will I continue? Until I become sixty or sixty-five years old.”

 If you reflect carefully, rebellion is now included in his sin. Earlier, he was merely a sinner committing wrongdoing plainly, but now a kind of arrogance has entered into it. What does this attitude really mean in simple words? It means: “I will not return. I will not repent until I reach sixty or sixty-five.” This attitude is actually an act of arrogance and defiance (istikbār).

 About such a person, Allah says: “I will not spare him.” At another place, Allah used a very powerful expression: Yes indeed, whoever earns evil and his sins surround him completely…”

 Meaning: at first, a person merely commits a sin — that was still manageable. But then his sins begin to encompass him entirely. His mornings and evenings become immersed in wrongdoing. Then a third thing is added: he mentally plans that he has no intention of returning until he has spent a certain age in sin. About such a person, Allah says that he will become deserving of eternal Hell. The Qur’an (2:81).

 And this matter should also be looked at from another angle: where did this person get the certainty that, after spending all those years in sin, he will even get the chance to repent? How did he become so sure? Even rationally, this is a false assumption. There is no logical basis for someone to plan that, “At old age I will repent.” Does anyone know the appointed time of death? One may suddenly be seized.

 The Qur’an gives a very striking picture: Say: the angel of death who has been appointed over you shall take your soul…” (Surah As-Sajdah 32:11). Notice the imagery. Allah says an angel has been assigned over you. What does “assigned” mean? For example, imagine a government appointing an intelligence officer over someone and instructing him: “Keep observing him. Do not let him out of your sight. The moment we command you, seize him.”

 That is what “appointed” conveys here. Allah says an angel has been assigned, as though he is constantly watching — observing one’s movements, one’s comings and goings — merely waiting for the command from God as to when he should take him away.

 When this is the reality, then how can someone make plans that “I will reform myself in old age”? It is impossible. The call may come at any moment. ___________________________________________________________________________________

 Question 3: When Allah is ultimately going to deal with me individually, and Allah has already declared that in the Hereafter, wealth, children, relatives — none of them will be of any benefit to me — then why should I spend my life with them? Why should I not instead live only for myself?

 Reply: The examination is indeed yours — but the question is: an examination in what?

 It is precisely through these relationships that you are being tested. You are given children, parents, brothers and sisters, a neighborhood, relatives, and loved ones. Then you are placed among them and told: this is how you are supposed to live with them this is your test.

 If you start thinking, “What concern do I have with these people?” then, in another sense, it means you have walked out of the examination hall altogether. Your test no longer even exists.

 You will notice that in certain mystical or ascetic traditions, this very mindset operates. They say, “If we remain in society, there will always be chances of becoming involved in sin. So let us renounce the world, retreat into forests, sit in caves, keep chanting God’s name, and then neither will we face worldly distractions nor become sinners.”

 But this strategy is actually a strategy of running away from the test. It is just as if someone were told, “You must cross this river, and we will test your swimming ability by seeing whether you can cross it or not.” And he replies: “Well, if I enter the river, there is a possibility that I may drown, so I simply will not enter it at all.”

 That is exactly the situation here. Wherever God sends us in life, it is as though He has already prepared a testing environment and placed us into it. Now your task is not to run away. Your task is to remain within these very circumstances and adopt the correct attitude and conduct. That is your examination: Steadfast and balanced conduct. ___________________________________________________________________________________ 

Question 4: Now we often say that we should prepare for the Hereafter. And you just mentioned that the time of death is unknown. So a common question arises: if a person keeps all his focus only on the fact that “I will die one day and I will be held accountable before God,” then should he concentrate only on worship and righteous deeds?

 What about all the inventions, discoveries, and worldly advancements we see around us? This question comes up very frequently in such discussions.

 So, how much attention should we give to worldly matters, and how should we manage our worldly life in such a way that our journey toward the Hereafter also remains sound while our worldly life too becomes productive and successful?

 Reply: Things have to be managed step by step, side by side. For example, I was just coming from Faisalabad by bus. Now, among the fifty passengers on the bus, not everyone can have the same mindset. Some may be religiously inclined, while others may have no religious inclination at all and may be purely worldly people. But notice something carefully: both of them traveled. In the same way, neither that person’s worldliness nor this person’s religiosity affected the actual journey.

 Exactly on the same principle, when you live in this world, you also have to study worldly sciences and progress in them. These are unavoidable requirements of living in the world. Human needs will exist, and therefore inventions will also exist.

 Now, within this process of living in the world and studying these disciplines and advancing in them, both a religious person and a non-religious person can participate. Both can make the journey, and both are capable of making inventions. There is no issue in that regard.

 In fact, if you need a practical example, then study the earlier Muslim era. The Muslims among us were themselves producing these things and creating this body of knowledge. People from outside the Muslim world were not the ones doing it. So this itself is proof that our method of seeking knowledge makes it possible to do all these things while remaining within religion. None of this is hindered by faith.

 However, I would like to make an overall comment here: despite all this, there still remains a difference. And that difference is this: when you are a religious person, your faith influences your decisions.

 For example, take the case of travel again. Two people may both be traveling, but one person may have one purpose behind the journey, while the other has a completely different purpose. One may be traveling somewhere to serve the religion, while another may leave home in order to go somewhere and commit wrongdoing. The journey is the same, but the moral value changes.

 Likewise, whether you study worldly sciences as a religious person or as a purely worldly person, the rules and mechanics of the sciences themselves will not create any obstacle. What changes is the moral and spiritual value attached to your actions.

 But even here, the important point that should remain before us is this: if at some point you begin to feel that these sciences and disciplines are entangling you to such an extent that your next life — the Hereafter — is disappearing from your sight, then you should not pursue them in that way.

 This is not only the demand of religion; it is also the demand of reason.

 If the price of worldly inventions becomes your Hereafter, then what would religion demand from you? Think about it rationally: between a temporary life of a few days and an eternal life, which one would you prefer? Obviously, the eternal life.

 Religiously as well, the matter is the same. If a situation ever arises where you are forced to choose only one of the two paths and there is no third option available, then as a believer, you should understand that if you personally do not make an invention, the world’s progress will not stop. Many people are already engaged in these fields and are doing excellent work. It is not necessary that I myself must accomplish it.

 But if my Hereafter is being ruined because of it, then I should give greater attention to my Hereafter instead.  _________________________________________________________________________________

Question 5: Please shed some light on this situation: suppose there is a doctor who is also a Muslim, and whose goal is also the Hereafter. Among his fundamental responsibilities here is that he has to take care of a patient, and he has even taken an oath that he will not compromise on the patient’s health.

 Now, if during an operation the time for prayer arrives, and he skips the prayer to continue with the operation, then how should this attitude be viewed?

 Reply: So this is actually his commitment, isn’t it? You are looking at it from one angle as a worldly commitment — that he must care for the patient and look after him. But if you look at it from another perspective, it is actually a demand of his religion as well. It is a religious obligation because of the agreement he has entered into, and even if there were no formal agreement, the patient still has rights over him. The patient is in a vulnerable state, perhaps even dying — how can the doctor become indifferent to him? He has to save him, regardless of whether he formally took an oath or not. And when he performs this duty, he is in fact acting upon his religion.

 Now let us come to the second matter: prayer. Did God make prayer obligatory upon you in such a way that under no circumstances would you ever be given any concession regarding its timing? Or is the matter actually the opposite — that concessions have indeed been given in timing?

 You know that in our religion, prayers can even be combined.

 Now imagine a doctor standing in an operating theater. He has already made an incision in the patient. Obviously, after making the incision, he cannot simply say, “Let me go and offer the prayer right now.” We are talking about situations where major surgeries sometimes continue for four or five hours, and during that time, the doctors cannot even move away from their positions.

 In fact, some time ago, a doctor asked me this very question, and I told him, “First, take care of your patient. God has not imposed such a restriction upon you that even in this circumstance, you must pray exactly at that moment.” Allah has granted concession for such situations. Once you are free, you may combine the prayers and offer them together.

 And this kind of situation is not unprecedented. During the time of the Prophet , on the occasion of the Battle of the Trench (Ghazwah al-Khandaq), the Muslims were stationed at the defensive lines and did not even get the opportunity to offer the prayers on time, so they later made them up as missed prayers.

 So the point is this: when you are living in the world and acting according to moral principles, then in reality you are already acting upon religion itself. These responsibilities should not be viewed as something standing in opposition to religion. Rather, they themselves should be understood as commands and demands of religion. _________________________________________________________________________________

And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” Qur’an 28:77

 Source: Mr. Rizwanullah, Scholar Al Mawrid, Lahore 

_________________________________________________________________________________ 

Arranged by:
Aamir I. Yazdani
MPhil Islamic Thought & Civilization (PAKISTAN)
MSc Irrigation Engineering (UK)

The Moment of Reckoning - I by Mr. Rizwanullah (Translated in English)

Epigraph: “And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” Qur’an 28:77 

 Source Note: This is a direct English rendering of a recorded discussion between Mr. Rizwanullah (Scholar, Al Mawrid, Lahore) and young participants. The content has been translated faithfully into English with grammatical refinement, without interpretive additions.

 The Analogy of Travelling
Upon reflection, travel offers many valuable lessons. One kind of journey is where you simply depart, remain completely unconcerned about what is happening around you, fall asleep, and arrive at your destination. However, if you travel with full awareness and attentiveness, you gain ever-new observations, and your experience increases significantly. 

When a journey begins, and you take your seat, initially, there is a feeling of reassurance and comfort. Your attention is focused on somehow settling into your place and adjusting yourself. The most important thing at that moment seems to be securing a seat. Once you get your place, you attain a little peace and comfort. But as you continue moving forward, and as different stations and destinations pass by, changes also begin to occur in your temperament and state of mind.

 Let me give you a simple example. When we were children and used to travel, at the beginning, there would simply be the usual struggle of settling down in the train and making space for ourselves. Five or ten minutes would pass in that. After that came the stage where we would sit by the window and observe the outside scenery: the trees seeming to move backward, rivers appearing, canals flowing, and flowers passing by. Then, as we neared our destination, before our station arrived, our mother would especially tell us: “Get up and prepare yourselves — the station is about to come.”

 In the light of this, if you reflect carefully, life too is very much like a journey. It also has its stages and stopping points along the way, and then there is a final destination to which everyone must inevitably go, whether they wish to or not. The first stage is childhood and adolescence. Then youth turns into adulthood. After that begins the phase of middle age, then old age, and finally death.

 Childhood
If you observe a child, you will notice that the child lives a completely carefree and contented life. There is neither concern nor thought about the unseen future. The child simply lives in his own world, making decisions according to his own understanding. Whatever is directly before his eyes becomes his focus and center of attention.

 Youth
Then comes the next stage in the journey of life: youth. In youth, passion is stronger, enthusiasm is greater, activity and movement are more intense, and a person becomes involved in countless engagements and pursuits. It is as though he is constantly running forward with excitement overpowering him. In that stage too, true awareness is often absent.

 Middle Age
But when one enters middle age, it feels as though that earlier intensity and passion begin to soften. Emotions become more balanced. The passions and ambitions that once burned strongly begin to settle, while maturity and awareness increase. The Qur’an too refers to this stage of intellectual and emotional maturity: “Until he reaches full maturity and reaches forty years of age…”

Onset of Old Age
Around forty years is generally the stage where, if you imagine life as climbing a mountain, you have reached the peak in many respects. After that, the downward slope begins. Then the signs of old age start appearing. Your hair begins turning white. Your joints begin wearing down. Your eyesight weakens. Earlier, you could see clearly from afar, but now doctors tell you that you need glasses. These changes begin appearing one after another.

 Tell-Tale Signs
What are all these things actually telling you? They are telling you that your final station is approaching. So what should one do? As I mentioned earlier, our mother would say, “Gather your bags and belongings together — the station is near.” In the same way, at this stage of life, your task should no longer be scattering and expanding endlessly into worldly pursuits; rather, it should be gathering yourself together and preparing.

 Yet even at this age, some people remain entirely occupied with plans related only to this world. You may have seen people who, even with one foot almost in the grave, continue making worldly plans — striving for further success, advancement, and accumulation. Whereas what should really happen is that the direction toward which you are inevitably heading should now become your focus, and preparation for that destination should begin.

 You may dye your white hair and hide its color. One meaning of doing so could simply be appearance and grooming. But another possibility is this: Allah had shown you a sign — as though warning bells had begun ringing that your station is approaching — yet instead of taking heed, you try to hide the reminder itself. It is as though a person says, “I still do not want to think of myself as old. I do not want to feel any such concern. I still wish to remain absorbed in the pleasures and distractions of this world.”

 What I am saying is that in the journey of life, when the signs of old age begin, it is as though the signs of death have also begun. At that point, a person should begin preparing. Preparing for what? For the station where he must eventually disembark — inevitably and without escape. As the Qur’an says: “Indeed, you are laboring steadily toward your Lord, and you will surely meet Him.” — Qur’an 84:6

 Whether willingly or unwillingly, you are moving toward that meeting. No matter how much a person struggles, he cannot refuse to arrive at that destination.

 Moment of Reflection
Now, the reality I have placed before you is something people often fail to keep in mind. There are several reasons for this, some of which are mentioned in the Qur’an and also discussed in the sayings of Muhammad.

 For example, especially in youth, a person feels that life ahead is still very long. Youth carries its own excitement, ambitions, and romantic idealism. A young person thinks: “I am still young. Old age and death are far away. There is still plenty of time before I need to prepare.” But this is actually a deception. Ordinarily, yes, people move through all these stages one after another. But it is not Allah’s fixed rule that every individual must necessarily reach old age before death.

 A person who assumes in youth that “my destination is still far away, so preparation can wait,” should remember that sudden death also exists. Many people are healthy, young, and apparently fine in every way — yet they suddenly depart from this world.

 Some people think differently. They say, “Even if we die, Judgment Day will not come immediately. You yourself tell us that there is the عالمِ برزخ (the intermediate realm). That period may last thousands of years. Then the Day of Judgment will occur, then a new world will be created, and only after that will we stand before Allah’s court.”

 But here too, a person is falling into another form of deception. He becomes spiritually lazy, thinking that there is still a very long time ahead. The Prophet Muhammad explained this beautifully in a Hadith. He said: Whoever dies, his Qiyamah has already begun.” Meaning: even if thousands of years remain before the Final Day arrives, for the person who has died, his opportunity is already over.

 It is like a student sitting in an examination hall with three hours allotted for the exam. But after only one hour, his answer sheet is taken away. Even if two more hours remain officially, what benefit are they to him now? He can no longer write anything. In this sense, the Prophet said:Whoever dies, his Judgment has already commenced.”

 Conclusion
We were discussing how, as these earthly stages of life keep passing by, sometimes the awareness slips out of a person’s mind that the moment of accountability is drawing near. Therefore, God repeatedly reminds us of this in the Qur’an, keeps bringing it before us again and again. Like that famous verse: The people’s time of reckoning has drawn very near, yet they remain in heedlessness, turning away.”

 Now, what does heedlessness (ghaflah) mean here? Keep the earlier example in your mind — suppose you are traveling and you fall asleep. What does sleeping mean in that situation? It means that before reaching your stop, the preparations you were supposed to make are now left undone because you fell asleep. So the Qur’an explains that one of the greatest obstacles, one of the greatest barriers that prevents a person from keeping God’s accountability before him, is this heedlessness. We fall asleep spiritually.

 If a person remains awake to the fact that the moment of accountability is approaching, then naturally he will prepare for it. These two things are inseparable — understand this carefully. For example, when educational institutions announce, “The examinations are near,” what does that actually mean? Does it mean: “Go to sleep”? No. The very purpose of announcing that examinations are near is to say: “Wake up, become alert, prepare yourselves, come out of negligence — very little time remains.”

 The Qur’anic expression is: Iqtaraba linnāsi hisābuhum” : “The people’s reckoning has come very close.”

 So in the end, we simply pray to Allah that He creates within us this awareness and consciousness: that while we continue living our worldly lives, we never forget that in the Hereafter we will have to give an account of our affairs, and that moment is not very far away at all. It is as though it is right upon our heads.

________________________________________________________________________________

And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” Qur’an 28:77

 Source: Mr. Rizwanullah, Scholar Al Mawrid, Lahore

________________________________________________________________________________

 Arranged by:

Aamir I. Yazdani
MPhil Islamic Thought & Civilization (PAKISTAN)
MSc Irrigation Engineering (UK)


Thursday, May 21, 2026

Is the Opinion of the Majority (Jumhur) a Binding Proof? - By Dr. Muhammad Akram Nadwi


 Is the Opinion of the Majority (Jumhur) a Binding Proof?

By Dr. Muhammad Akram Nadwi

[Source Note: This is a direct English rendering of the article by Dr. Muhammad Akram Nadwi. The content has been translated faithfully into English with grammatical refinement, without interpretive additions.]
 

Some matters are so baseless that no serious and occupied person wishes to waste time discussing them. One such notion, however, has been circulating on social media for several years: “The opinion of the majority is a binding proof,” “Opposing the majority is misguidance,” “Truth depends upon the opinion of the majority,” “Whoever departs from the way of the majority risks losing his faith,” and similar statements.

I continued ignoring such claims, considering them unworthy of attention, assuming they were merely another wave of nonsense common on social media. Coincidentally, today, a similar post was shared in a WhatsApp group. As usual, I ignored it. Suddenly, a respected scholar directed the discussion toward me. These days, life is so busy that one naturally avoids such futile matters. Yet I thought that if scholars themselves have begun treating such falsehoods as worthy of consideration, then a remedy has become necessary; otherwise, a new innovation may take root in religion.

In both Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, there is a narration from Aisha bint Abi Bakr in which the Prophet said: “Whoever introduces into this matter of ours something that does not belong to it, it is rejected.”

Out of fear that this irrational idea may become part of God’s pure religion, I have decided to put these thoughts into writing. May Allah grant us all the ability to follow the truth.

The question posed in the title of this article can be fully answered by dividing the discussion into three sections:

  1. The obligatory/practical response
  2. The cause of the confusion
  3. The scholarly/research-based response

1. The Practical Response

Those who repeatedly raise this issue are generally followers of one of the four schools of jurisprudence — Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, or Hanbali. Since the majority in the Indian subcontinent are Hanafis, examples will be drawn from the Hanafi school.

The first question to such people is: if the opinion of the majority is truly a binding proof, then what justification remains for following the Hanafi school? In every issue, you should act upon the opinion held by the majority.

According to Abu Hanifa, the time of Zuhr prayer ends when the shadow becomes twice the object’s length, whereas the majority of jurists and hadith scholars hold that it ends at the first shadow length. If the majority’s opinion is truly binding, then fairness demands abandoning Imam Abu Hanifa’s opinion and following the majority.

Similarly:

  • Imam Abu Hanifa considered Witr obligatory, while the majority regard it as Sunnah.
  • Hanafi books mention four non-emphasized Sunnah rak‘ahs before ‘Isha, whereas no such practice is authentically reported from the Companions, the Successors, or the four Imams.
  • Imam Abu Hanifa held that the opening Takbir is valid with any phrase glorifying God, while the majority disagree.
  • According to Imam Abu Hanifa, intention is not a condition for the validity of ablution, while the majority say that ablution without intention is invalid.
  • Imam Abu Hanifa considered purification during Tawaf obligatory, whereas the majority considered it a condition.
  • Imam Abu Hanifa allowed a woman’s marriage without a guardian, while the majority require a guardian.

Every school contains hundreds of such issues where the majority opinion was not followed. If the majority’s opinion were obligatory, why would these schools insist upon their own views?


2. The Cause of the Confusion

The confusion arises because these people fail to distinguish between narration and opinion.

If a hadith is transmitted through a connected chain of trustworthy narrators, and another hadith with a sound chain exists in opposition to it, then which narration receives preference?

The agreed position of scholars is that the narration whose transmitters possess stronger precision and reliability is preferred. If both chains are equal in precision, then preference is determined by supporting chains and multiplicity of transmission. The stronger narration is called محفوظ (preserved), and the weaker one شاذ (anomalous).

Thus, in matters of narration, the number of transmitters can sometimes become a factor of preference.

But opinions are different.

In matters of opinion, preference depends upon the strength of evidence. The opinion supported by stronger evidence is stronger; the one supported by weaker evidence remains weak. Even if the entire world votes in favor of the weaker opinion, it still remains weak and anomalous.


3. The Scholarly Response

The claim that “the opinion of the majority is a binding proof” contradicts:

  • the Qur’an,
  • the Sunnah,
  • the consensus of the Muslim Ummah,
  • reason itself,
  • and the continuous scholarly practice of Muslim jurists across generations.

The Qur’an repeatedly makes obedience to Allah and His Messenger obligatory. For example: “O you who believe! Obey Allah, obey the Messenger, and those in authority among you.” — Qur’an 4:59

Based upon such verses, the Ummah unanimously agreed that:

  1. The first proof is the Book of Allah.
  2. The second proof is the Sunnah of the Messenger.

Obedience to those in authority exists under obedience to Allah and His Messenger.

Then Allah says: “If you differ in anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and the Messenger.”

Meaning: when scholars or authorities differ, the matter must be referred back to the Qur’an and Sunnah. The view most consistent with them is the stronger view.

The Qur’an commands decisions based upon evidence — not numbers. In fact, the Qur’an strongly indicates that if the majority’s opinion lacks evidence, rejecting it becomes obligatory, and blindly following the majority without proof becomes misguidance.

The Prophet also emphasized this principle. In Sahih Muslim, Jabir ibn Abd Allah narrates:

“I leave among you that which, if you hold firmly to it, you will never go astray after me: the Book of Allah.”

A narration in Al-Mustadrak ala al-Sahihayn also mentions the Sunnah alongside it.

The famous hadith of Muadh ibn Jabal likewise directs people first to the Book of Allah, then to the Sunnah of the Messenger, and thereafter to analogy (Qiyas).

Some narrations also command adherence to the Sunnah of the rightly guided caliphs. Yet no hadith states that, in cases of disagreement, the majority opinion becomes automatically authoritative.


From the era of the Companions onward, all jurists, hadith scholars, and scholars generally agreed that the proofs are the Qur’an and Sunnah.

Most jurists — except the Zahiris — also accepted consensus (Ijma‘) and analogy (Qiyas) as legal proofs. But no jurist ever declared the opinion of the majority itself to be an independent proof.

The books of Usul al-Fiqh from the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, and Hanbali schools exist in abundance. They count consensus as proof, but none considers the majority opinion itself a proof.

Reason also dictates that the correct view is the one supported by evidence. A claim without evidence remains weak, even if the entire world supports it.

This is why democracy itself is not considered proof of truth.

Many beliefs once universally accepted by nations were later disproven by scientific inquiry.

Even members of Tablighi Jamaat repeatedly emphasize this point. During their consultations, it is specifically stated that the Amir is not bound to decide according to majority opinion.


The historical practice of jurists clearly proves that the majority’s opinion is not binding proof.

If you study the books of all schools and the commentaries on hadith, you will repeatedly find statements such as “this is the opinion of the majority,” yet no jurist treats majority agreement itself as evidence. Rather, those opposing the majority present proofs for their position.

This clearly demonstrates that evidence is what matters — not numbers.

Otherwise, anyone opposing the majority would have been obligated to abandon his view merely because he stood in the minority. Yet no scholar ever abandoned his position solely because the majority disagreed.

If the Hanafis began blindly following the majority, the Hanafi school itself would disappear.


Conclusion

Calling people to follow the majority is an unacademic and irrational call. The invitation should always be toward following evidence.

In this religion, the universally agreed proofs are the Qur’an and Sunnah. Other disputed proofs also exist, foremost among them consensus and analogy.

Whenever a person presents an opinion, he is obligated to support it with evidence from these sources.

Merely chanting “majority, majority” in place of evidence is manifest misguidance. It effectively declares the Companions, the Successors, the four Imams, and all jurists and hadith scholars to have been mistaken.

Arranged by:
Aamir I. Yazdani
MPhil Islamic Thought & Civilization (PAKISTAN)
MSc Irrigation Engineering (UK)

Monday, May 18, 2026

An Ode To A Dear Childhood Gallian Friend Who Left Us Far Too Early


 18th May — my dear childhood Gallian friend, Sohail Javed’s birthday. He left us over two decades ago, yet the memories remain as vivid as ever.

Sohail Javed joined Lawrence College Ghora Gali the same year I did, in 1976, in Senior School, Class VIII. From the very beginning, he was gentle, soft-spoken, and noble in temperament. Our beds in the dormitory remained side by side throughout our years in GG, until we left after our Intermediate Board examinations in 1981.

In Class IX, Sohail used to narrate incidents late at night, in a hushed voice before sleep, from the famous Islamic horror books Maut ka Manzar and Marnay Kay Baad Kya Hoga. Those eerie narrations still send shudders down my spine.

He was firmly against my smoking. Once in Class XII, Alamzeb and I were smoking secretly on the terrace after lights out. Suddenly, Sohail stepped out of the dormitory. I quickly passed the cigarette to Alamzeb, who dramatically exhaled smoke to make it appear as though he alone was smoking. Sohail instantly understood the whole scene. Looking straight at me with mock annoyance, he remarked:
“Keep smoking! You’re the one who’ll die!”
…and quietly walked back inside. Alamzeb and I burst into laughter.

My prayers in the College mosque were often alongside Sohail Javed. At times, we would even offer Tahajjud together late at night in the Babar House common room. Those moments now feel timeless.

I still remember one amusing incident vividly. Once on the College field, while talking to Sohail, I casually used the famous GG expression “bloody fool.” Unfortunately, the Principal, Brigadier Safdar Nawab, happened to overhear me from atop the field.

The next day, our House Master, Mr. Najam, summoned us and conveyed the Principal’s displeasure. Then, turning to Sohail, he asked:
“Why didn’t you stop Yazdani from using that language?”

Sohail, in his trademark innocence and simplicity, replied:
“Sir… mein bhool gaya tha.”
(“Sir… I forgot.”)

Mr. Najam could not help smiling wryly.

Sohail’s mother had passed away before he joined GG. In Class VIII, I was perhaps the only one in whom he confided this deeply personal sorrow. I still remember him showing me a small newspaper cutting carrying the news of her death — a treasured keepsake he carried with him. Even at that young age, one could sense the quiet grief he bore within.

Today, I find myself flooded with memories of those irreplaceable years spent with Sohail Javed — memories wrapped in affection, innocence, youth, friendship, and loss. And yes, with a tear in my eye.

Rest well and easy, dear Sohail. Souls as noble and gentle as yours deserve nothing less than Allah’s mercy, pleasure, and eternal peace. May Allah bless you abundantly, elevate your ranks, shower His mercy upon you, and protect your beloved family, children, and spouse. Ameen.

And perhaps — by Allah’s grace — we shall meet one day again.

And when we do, my prayer is that we relive once more those immortal summers of Lawrence College Ghora Gali from 1976 to 1981.

— Aamir Yazdani

 

Enter My Paradise: A Son Remembers His Mother - “They don’t make ’em like her anymore.”



 Suggested Reading Time: 7–8 Minutes

Epigraph

“O soul at peace, return to your Lord, well-pleased and pleasing. So enter among My servants, and enter My Paradise.” — Qur’an 89:27–30

“Our Lord! Forgive me, my parents, and the believers on the Day when the reckoning is established.” — Qur’an 14:41


18th May 2022

Today, it has been four years since my dear Ammi passed away.

This happened before my eyes. She was lying in her room, upon her bed. With three long breaths, the fourth one was cut short. My mother was received by the angel of death. She remained blessed with a full life that extended into her mid‑eighties.

I stayed with her throughout most of my life, except for a few years when I left for education and greener pastures. Yet perhaps the most beautiful part of my life with her remains the bond she shared with my three children. Ammi was at her happiest with them. She thrived on exchanging humour, playful acts, and endless anecdotes with her grandchildren.

Ammi was a disciplinarian and a pre‑partition alumna of Pindi Convent. One incident from my childhood remains etched permanently in my memory. Back in 1975, when I was in Class 7, I returned home from school and became absorbed in outdoor play, ignoring Ammi’s repeated calls for lunch. Eventually, when I finally appeared and asked for food, she calmly replied: “The lunch is there, but you shall not have it.”

I can safely say that from that very day onward, I have never delayed my meals.


Lawrence College and a Mother’s Determination

In 1976, Ammi placed me in boarding school at Lawrence College, Murree, when I entered Class 8. My academic performance at the time was not particularly impressive, and so Ammi regularly undertook a difficult journey from Jhelum along with my younger brother, Arif.

She would leave early in the morning on a private, non‑air‑conditioned bus to Rawalpindi, then walk quite a distance to another stop from where she boarded a Murree‑bound bus to Bansra Gali. From there, she walked nearly two kilometers uphill to the college gate, followed by another considerable downward walk toward the Senior School.

This was the rudimentary version of what today would be called a parent‑teacher meeting.

My Ammi walked that entire route repeatedly.

After meeting my teachers in the staff room, I would accompany her back to Bansra Gali, waving goodbye with tears in my eyes as she departed for Jhelum with Arif.

Years later, while I was studying engineering at university in Lahore, she would teasingly ask me with twinkling eyes: “Do I need to come and meet your university professor as well?”


East Pakistan, Marriage, and the Loss of Asif

My mother married my father in the spring of 1957 and moved with him to East Pakistan — present‑day Bangladesh — where my father worked as an engineer for the British Steamer Company.

That was the beginning of a completely new chapter in her life.

Their first child, my eldest brother Asif, was born there. My father, being a young engineer at the time, lived aboard a steamer, and my mother lived there with him.

Tragically, Asif passed away from dehydration at only eight months old in 1958.

Neither my father nor my mother ever forgot him.

How could they?

The memory of Asif remained permanently etched within their hearts till their very last days.


My Children and Their Dadi

I married a lovely, gentle woman, Hureen, and we continued living with our parents throughout. My parents thoroughly enjoyed the company of our children.

At times, my eldest son Waleed’s endless antics would exhaust his mother, who would naturally wish to discipline him. Waleed, however, would instantly rush into my parents’ room and hide between Dada and Dadi. My parents would protect him and reassure Hureen: “We will take care of the matter.”

When Waleed was admitted to Cadet College Hasanabdal in 2005, my Ammi travelled with us to settle him into his dormitory. She prepared his bed and cupboard exactly the way she had done for me nearly three decades earlier at Lawrence College.

My middle son, Khalid, loved listening to Winnie the Pooh before bedtime while drinking his nightly milk. His Dadi faithfully read the stories to him every evening. Since Khalid adored pets, Dadi ensured he always had one around — a pigeon, a parrot, a hen, a rabbit, a Labrador.

Later, when Khalid too entered boarding school, Dadi repeated the same ritual of helping him settle into his dormitory.

My youngest son, Ahmed, once remarked to his mother:

“Whenever I leave for school, I always see Dadi giving two biscuits to Dada with his tea.”

The next day, when my wife narrated this to Ammi, she smilingly replied to Ahmed:

“Whenever I give biscuits to Dada, you somehow seem to be passing by our room!”

It took Ahmed some time to fully appreciate the humour behind that response.


After My Father’s Passing

My father passed away early in the morning on 29th April 2012.

After his passing, Ammi would sometimes call me “Zafar” while I sat beside her in the evening.

And why not?

She had never, even for a moment, allowed herself to emotionally detach from her husband.

At times she would quietly confide in me that she wished to be with Zafar again.

And why should she not?

God created the very first human pair upon earth as husband and wife. This bond remains among the deepest and most foundational of all human relationships.

During those years, my youngest son, Ahmed, began sleeping in Ammi’s room. He became a great source of comfort and strength for her.

After Fajr prayer, Ammi would recite the Qur’an and switch on the room light, while Ahmed would repeatedly switch it off, complaining that his sleep was being disturbed. Ammi thoroughly enjoyed this playful battle.

In the mornings, while seated upon her bedside sofa, she would gently tickle Ahmed’s feet with her walking stick to wake him up for school.

My children kept their grandmother emotionally engaged till the very end. All three of them frequently spent time in her room doing their activities around her.


Her Final Years

Gradually, Ammi began fading away.

I could see the brightness in her eyes slowly dimming, and I realized the inevitable was approaching.

My wife cared for her devotedly. Whenever she accompanied Ammi to the hospital, doctors would often ask whether she was her daughter. My wife knew every detail of her medicines, treatment, and medical condition.

Ammi lovingly referred to her as:

“My Florence Nightingale.”

During her later years, Ammi wrote her memoirs titled Anwar Nama. Her name was Anwar.

As her memory weakened, my elder brother Jamshed Bhai helped her recollect and organize her memories while typing them onto a laptop.

The concluding lines of her memoirs, dedicated to my father, borrowed from a famous Indian song:

“Zindagi aur kuch bhi nahin; teri meri kahani hai.”

Roughly translated:

“Life, in the end, is nothing but the story of you and me.”


Death and the Hereafter

One thing about death is that it does not end a person’s existence.

It is a gateway to eternity.

A life promised by Allah to those servants who remain conscious of fulfilling the rights of God and fellow human beings.

The Qur’an says:

“I always thought that one day I shall have to face my reckoning.” — Qur’an 69:20

Ammi’s life reflected this awareness.

Her actions remained in harmony with her words. She never neglected her prayers or fasting, and she consistently cared for the poor and needy.

The Qur’an beautifully describes such people:

“…they used to feed the poor, the orphan and the captive even though they themselves were in need of it.” — Qur’an 76:8

My parents once helped free an elderly couple who worked in our home from the crushing burden of debt. They had become trapped in an endless cycle of compound interest.

My father personally met the lender and paid both the principal and the accumulated interest.

The Qur’an says: “Charity is only… for the freeing of necks.” — Qur’an 9:60

May Allah free the necks of my parents in the Hereafter, as they did so for this elderly couple in debt. Ameen


What Parents Leave Behind

My parents continued striving till their very last days to instill goodness within me.

The Qur’an says: “A human being shall only receive in the Hereafter what he has earned in this world.” — Qur’an 53:39

I testify that whatever iota of goodness exists within me is the lifelong endeavour of my dear father and mother.

Whatever evil remains within me is from my own self.

May Allah reward our parents in the Hereafter for every goodness we exhibit in this life, for much of it is the direct consequence of their sacrifice, labour, prayers, discipline, and love.

Ameen.


Prayer

Allahummaghfir lahuma warhamhuma. Allahumma adkhilhuma al‑jannata ma‘a al‑abrar.

“O Allah, forgive my mother and father and shower them with Your mercy. O Allah, admit them into Paradise among the righteous.”

Ameen.

The Qur’an says:

“Those whose souls are taken by the angels while they are pure — the angels will say: ‘Peace be upon you. Enter Paradise for what you used to do.’” — Qur’an 16:32

May the angels have greeted my Ammi with these words.

Ameen.

And may the final divine call awaiting her be:

“O soul at peace, return to your Lord, well‑pleased and pleasing. So enter among My servants, and enter My Paradise.” — Qur’an 89:27–30


“They don’t make ’em like her anymore.”

Aamir Yazdani

 

The Moment of Reckoning – II (Q/A Session) by Mr. Rizwanullah (Translated in English)

Epigraph: “ And seek, through what Allah has given you, the Home of the Hereafter.” — Qur’an 28:77   Source Note: This is a direct Engl...